Once celebrated as one of the world’s top goalkeepers, Emiliano “Emi” Martínez now finds himself at a crossroads in his career. The Argentine star a World Cup winner with Argentina in 2022 and a key figure in Aston Villa’s rise to prominence has been stripped of his vice-captaincy by manager Unai Emery, signaling a possible shift in the club’s internal hierarchy.
This decision comes after a summer of transfer drama that saw Martínez almost leave Villa Park, with Manchester United emerging as the leading contender for his signature. The deal, however, never materialized, and since then, the relationship between the player and the club has appeared strained.
When Martínez joined Villa from Arsenal four years ago for roughly $23 million USD, few expected him to become one of the Premier League’s standout goalkeepers. His commanding presence and emotional leadership helped Aston Villa climb from mid-table mediocrity to a side capable of qualifying for European competitions.
But things have changed. Emery’s confirmation that Ezri Konsa has replaced Martínez as vice-captain speaks volumes about the club’s new direction. “The first captain is John McGinn,” Emery said. “Usually, we have Emi Martínez as second captain, but now Konsa is the next one.”
The announcement follows months of speculation about Martínez’s future. He was widely expected to leave last summer, with Manchester United showing interest. Reports suggest Villa valued their goalkeeper at $38 million USD, a figure that proved too steep for United, who ultimately opted to sign Senne Lammens from Royal Antwerp instead.
Martínez’s disappointment was visible. He cut an emotional figure in what many believed would be his final game at Villa Park last season.
This is not the first time Unai Emery has shown discontent with Martínez’s behavior. The manager has been vocal about maintaining discipline and professionalism within his squad, values that sometimes clash with the goalkeeper’s fiery personality.
Martínez, known for his outspoken and animated demeanor, has often drawn criticism for his on-field antics and emotional outbursts, both at club level and internationally. While such traits made him a cult hero during Argentina’s World Cup run, they have occasionally frustrated Emery, who favors focus and composure.
